Hotels in Shelter Island

    Check-In
    Check-Out
    Rooms/Guests 2 Person in 1 Room
    Popularity

    Stay in Style Explore Shelter Island Top-Rated Hotels

    • The Harbor Front Inn,209 Front St,4 star
    The Harbor Front Inn,209 Front St,4 star
    Southold>Greenport
    Free wi-fi
    4.25 km from shelter island
    Free Breakfast
    Free Cancellation
    Read more
    180
    + 25 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    Southold>Greenport
    Free wi-fi
    5.85 km from shelter island
    Free Breakfast
    Free Cancellation
    Read more
    226
    + 30 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    Southampton
    22.08 km from shelter island
    Read more
    153
    + 21 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    Old Saybrook
    25.05 km from shelter island
    Free Breakfast
    Free Cancellation
    Read more
    69
    + 20 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    Southampton>Hampton Bays
    27.73 km from shelter island
    Read more
    Excellent
    119 reviews
    4.5
    210
    + 29 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    Old Saybrook
    27.94 km from shelter island
    Free Breakfast
    Read more
    120
    + 17 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    East Lyme
    30.75 km from shelter island
    Read more
    256
    + 45 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    Riverhead
    31.44 km from shelter island
    Free Breakfast
    Read more
    166
    + 23 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    East Hampton>Montauk
    Free wi-fi
    32.62 km from shelter island
    Read more
    215
    + 29 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    East Hampton>Montauk
    Free wi-fi
    33.79 km from shelter island
    Free Cancellation
    Read more
    Very Good
    291 reviews
    4.4
    314
    + 43 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    East Lyme
    Free wi-fi
    34.05 km from shelter island
    Free Cancellation
    Read more
    86
    + 13 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    East Lyme
    34.2 km from shelter island
    Free Breakfast
    Read more
    93
    + 27 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    East Lyme
    34.32 km from shelter island
    Free Cancellation
    Read more
    72
    + 11 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    Riverhead
    34.41 km from shelter island
    Free Breakfast
    Free Cancellation
    Read more
    169
    + 22 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    Riverhead
    35.53 km from shelter island
    Free Breakfast
    Read more
    144
    + 20 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    Riverhead
    35.6 km from shelter island
    Read more
    162
    + 22 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    Riverhead
    Free wi-fi
    36.15 km from shelter island
    Free Breakfast
    Free Cancellation
    Read more
    175
    + 24 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    Guilford
    36.22 km from shelter island
    Free Breakfast
    Free Cancellation
    Read more
    229
    + 32 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    New London
    37.85 km from shelter island
    Free Breakfast
    Free Cancellation
    Read more
    188
    + 26 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    Waterford
    38.43 km from shelter island
    Free Breakfast
    Read more
    232
    + 33 Taxes & fees
    Per Night
    View Room
    Login &Save More
    Arrow Up Icon
    }